Wicked Pantages, the fascinating and fabulous hit Broadway musical, tells the myriad story of the legendary witches of Oz. It is played at the Gershwin Theatre. Wicked Pantages has opened in London with Idina Menzel as the first Elphaba. Wicked Pantages (film), a 1998 film starring Julia Stiles.Wicked Pantages brings to life the sensational story of how misunderstood, green girl named Elphaba became the Wicked Pantages Witch of the West Wicked Pantages has proved to be a super hit show. According to its co-producer David Stone, It has a $26 million advance and is palying with great success in the 1,800-seat Gershwin Theatre.